A Missing Medal and a $319 Photograph Preserve Bobby Jones’ East Lake Triumph

A Missing Medal and a $319 Photograph Preserve Bobby Jones’ East Lake Triumph

 

 

Bobby Jones celebrates his eight-stroke victory in the 1927 Southern Open at East Lake. PSA authenticated the 6-by-8-inch period photograph as Type I, and Golden Age Auctions sold it for $319.20, including buyer’s premium, in June 2023. Courtesy of Golden Age Auctions.

 

The FedEx Cup trophy will command most of the attention at East Lake this week. Ninety-nine years ago, the prize that mattered there was small enough to be worn around someone’s neck.

That medal belonged to Bobby Jones, who won the 1927 Southern Open at his home club by eight strokes. For years, serious collectors believed the award was missing. It had not disappeared. It had simply remained within the Jones family, outside the institutional collection where researchers expected to find it.

A second artifact from the same tournament eventually followed a very different path. An original news photograph of Jones celebrating the victory surfaced at Golden Age Auctions and sold in 2023 for $319.20.

The medal and photograph are not equivalent objects. One is the award placed in the winner’s hands. The other is a period image made to carry news of the win. Viewed together, they show why provenance and context matter more than size or price.

The East Lake Victory Behind Both Objects

The Southern Open brought professionals to East Lake in March 1927. Jones was already one of golf’s dominant figures, but he remained an amateur and earned his living away from tournament golf.

At East Lake, there was no ambiguity about who controlled the week. Jones posted 281 for 72 holes and won by eight strokes. It was one of the relatively few open events against professional competition that he captured during his amateur career.

That distinction is important. A U.S. Amateur medal connects Jones to the championship that defined much of his competitive identity. The 1927 Southern Open medal connects him to another part of the story: the day the world-class amateur returned to the course that taught him the game and overwhelmed a professional field.

The Medal Collectors Could Not Find

According to a 2019 PGA Tour account, Jones’ Southern Open medal is slightly larger than a silver dollar. The Southern Golf Association crest appears on the front. The reverse carries the winner’s inscription, identifying the open championship in Atlanta, the March 1927 date, Robert T. Jones Jr. and his 281 total. The Tour described the reverse as engraved in 14-karat gold.

Its provenance is unusually personal. Jones donated his championship medals to the USGA, but this first-place award was absent from that collection. Golf historians knew there should have been a medal from the 1927 Southern Open, yet its location was not generally understood.

Bob Jones IV, the golfer’s grandson, had it. The 2019 account describes Jones and his wife, Mimi, arriving at a reception while she wore the medal. Sidney Matthew, a noted Jones historian and author, immediately recognized it as the award collectors had been trying to locate.

The story is a useful reminder that “missing” can be a researcher’s word rather than an owner’s reality. Nothing in the public account suggests the medal had been stolen, discarded or separated from the family. It was missing only from the documentary trail collectors were following.

For publication purposes, the safest current wording is that the medal was in Jones family custody when the PGA Tour reported the story in August 2019. I found no later public record establishing a sale, transfer or present display location. There is also no responsible market price to attach to it.

The Photograph That Entered the Market

The second object is easier to track because its auction record is public. Golden Age Auctions offered a 6-by-8-inch original photograph showing Jones celebrating his Southern Open victory. A printed slug on the reverse called him the “King of Clubs,” the sort of newsroom language that gives an old press photograph a second layer of period character.

Professional Sports Authenticator classified the photograph as Type I. Under PSA’s system, that means it is a first-generation print developed from the original negative within approximately two years of the image being made. For collectors, that classification separates a period object from a later reproduction of the same scene.

The image was offered in Golden Age’s Summer 2023 Auction, which closed June 24, 2023. The archived lot page records a realized price of $319.20. Golden Age states that its displayed prices include the buyer’s premium.

That result should be treated as a dated sale record, not a current valuation. It tells us what one authenticated photograph brought in one auction, with its particular size, condition, presentation and bidding audience. It does not establish what another print would sell for today.

Why the Pair Is Stronger Than Either Object Alone

The medal has direct player provenance and a family story, but no public sale history. The photograph has third-party authentication and a clean auction record, but it was never owned by Jones merely because he appears in it.

That distinction is exactly what careful collecting requires. Subject, ownership and provenance are different things. A photograph of Jones is not automatically a Jones-owned object. A medal retained by his family is historically important even without an auction price.

Together, the two pieces fill gaps for one another. The engraving preserves the official result: Atlanta, March 1927, 281 strokes. The photograph preserves the public moment, with Jones no longer a line on a medal but the player who had just won at home.

For a collector drawn to Jones, East Lake or period golf photography, the lesson is not to chase whichever object carries the larger number. Look for specificity. Does the artifact identify an event? Can its date be established? Is the chain of ownership documented? Has a photograph been classified by a recognized authenticator? Does the auction record distinguish a sale price from an estimate?

Those questions do more than protect a purchase. They recover the history inside the object.

What These Artifacts Preserve

Jones’ 1927 Southern Open victory will never stand beside the Grand Slam in the usual summaries of his career. It deserves a place in the story for a different reason.

East Lake was where Jones learned by watching Stewart Maiden, where he tested his game and where Atlanta knew him before the rest of golf claimed him. The medal and photograph bring us back to a week when the world’s best amateur came home and beat the professionals by eight.

One artifact was kept close enough to wear. The other traveled through the marketplace for $319.20. Both carry the same thing forward: the record of Bobby Jones winning at the course that made him feel most at home.